The Different Types of Shoring Systems: A Complete Guide to Trench Safety

When it comes to excavation projects, soil stability is one of the most critical safety concerns. According to OSHA, trench cave-ins are among the deadliest hazards in construction, and protective systems are required for trenches deeper than 5 feet (or even shallower if conditions are unstable).

One of the most effective protective measures is shoring — the use of engineered supports to prevent trench wall collapses. But not all shoring systems are the same. Choosing the right one depends on soil type, trench depth, project duration, and site conditions.

Want the latest updates on hydrovac technology, safety practices, and excavation innovations? Subscribe to our free newsletter and get expert insights delivered straight to your inbox.

What Is Shoring in Excavation?

Shoring is a protective system used in trenching and excavation to support unstable soil and prevent cave-ins. Unlike sloping (cutting trench walls back at an angle) or shielding (trench boxes that protect workers without holding soil back), shoring actively reinforces excavation walls to keep soil in place.

Why Shoring Is Essential

  • Prevents fatalities and injuries from soil collapse.
  • Meets OSHA excavation standards (29 CFR 1926 Subpart P).
  • Protects underground utilities during hydro excavation and construction.
  • Ensures structural stability near roads, foundations, or heavy equipment.

The Different Types of Shoring Systems

1. Hydraulic Shoring

Hydraulic shoring is one of the most commonly used systems due to its speed, efficiency, and adaptability.

  • Uses prefabricated aluminum hydraulic cylinders combined with steel or aluminum plates.
  • Cylinders are pumped with fluid to pressurize and hold trench walls.
  • Easily adjustable and reusable.
  • Ideal for both short and long trenches.

Best For:
Contractors who need quick installation and flexibility across multiple soil types.

2. Pneumatic Shoring

Similar to hydraulic shoring but powered by air pressure instead of fluid.

  • Uses pneumatic cylinders to apply pressure.
  • Requires an air compressor on-site.
  • Lighter than hydraulic systems, making them easier to transport.

Best For:
Projects where compressed air is already available or where lightweight shoring is preferred.

3. Timber Shoring

A traditional system still used in certain conditions.

  • Involves timber uprights, cross braces, and sheathing to support trench walls.
  • Labor-intensive and slower to install than hydraulic systems.
  • Requires careful spacing based on soil classification.

Best For:
Projects in remote areas where prefabricated systems aren’t available or in irregular excavation sites.

4. Aluminum Hydraulic Shoring with Sheeting

A hybrid system that combines aluminum cylinders with plywood or steel sheeting.

  • Provides added stability for Type C soils (the least stable).
  • Lightweight and reusable.
  • Allows for wider, deeper trench protection.

Best For:
Utility projects where soil conditions are extremely unstable.

5. Screw Jack Shoring

A manual system that uses adjustable screw jacks instead of hydraulic pumps.

  • Workers adjust screw threads to press uprights against trench walls.
  • More labor-intensive than hydraulic systems.
  • No need for pumps or compressors.

Best For:
Smaller-scale projects where simplicity and cost savings are more important than speed.

6. Soldier Pile and Lagging (Heavy-Duty Shoring)

Used for deep excavations near roads, structures, or urban areas.

  • Steel H-piles (soldier piles) are driven into the ground.
  • Wood or concrete lagging is inserted between piles to support soil.
  • Often used in conjunction with tiebacks or bracing.

Best For:
Large infrastructure projects or deep excavations near highways and buildings.

7. Sheet Piling Shoring

A permanent or semi-permanent shoring method for deep and long-term excavations.

  • Steel sheets are driven vertically into the ground to create a retaining wall.
  • Highly durable and reusable.
  • Common in waterlogged or coastal excavation sites.

Best For:
Projects near water sources, harbors, or deep excavations where soil retention must be strong.

How to Choose the Right Shoring System

Factors to consider include:

Always ensure that a competent person evaluates soil and selects the appropriate system.

OSHA Requirements for Shoring

OSHA requires:

  • Protective systems in trenches 5 feet or deeper (unless in stable rock).
  • Designs approved by a registered professional engineer for trenches over 20 feet.
  • Regular inspections by a competent person, especially after rain, vibrations, or soil changes.

See OSHA Excavation Standards for official requirements.

Final Thoughts

The right shoring system can mean the difference between a safe, efficient excavation and a catastrophic cave-in. Whether you’re working with hydraulic shoring, timber systems, or heavy-duty soldier piles, compliance with OSHA standards and proper installation is non-negotiable.

Stay ahead in the hydro excavation industry. Subscribe today for top news, tech updates, innovations, events, insights, and exclusive classifieds for contractors, project managers, and industry owners.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Q1: What is the most common type of shoring?
Hydraulic shoring is the most commonly used due to its speed, adjustability, and safety.

Q2: How deep can shoring systems go?
Shoring systems can support trenches up to 20 feet deep without engineering approval; deeper systems require a professional design.

Q3: Is shoring always required?
Shoring is required for trenches 5 feet or deeper, unless the trench is cut in stable rock or protective alternatives (like sloping) are used.

Q4: Which shoring system is best for Type C soils?
Aluminum hydraulic shoring with sheeting or sheet piling are recommended for very unstable Type C soils.

Q5: Can trench boxes replace shoring?
Trench boxes (shielding) protect workers but do not support soil. They are different from shoring, though both are protective systems.